Marshall McLuhan on Historica Minutes


“The Medium is the Message” Marshall McLuhan and this Global Village

Peeks into a 1960s University of Toronto classroom as the world-renowned communications theorist fascinates students with his insights about mass media

Marshall McLuhan was a Canadian professor of English literature who burst into world prominence as a media guru in the 1960s. Working with the ideas of Harold Innis, another Canadian communications expert, McLuhan popularized the idea that our technologies have a profound effect on our lives, culture, and history.Countering the commonly accepted attitude that the content of a message is more important than its form, McLuhan pointed out that the means of communication itself creates an impact, regardless of what is being said. He claimed, for example, that a story has different meanings depending upon whether it is related orally, written in a book, acted out on the stage, heard on radio, presented on film, viewed on television, or depicted in a comic book. Each of these media has its own inherent bias and language, or, to put that principle into its now popular form: “the medium is the message.” McLuhan’s first major work, Gutenberg Galaxy, dealt with the effect of literacy on history. The invention of the alphabet, and then the printing press, resulted in the transition from oral to written culture. As the eye became the principal organ for taking in information, linear patterns and repeatable forms began to dominate our thinking and behaviour.

In his second major study, Understanding Media, McLuhan pointed out how electronic communication was again changing the way we perceive ourselves and our world. Technologies such as telephone, radio, and television were shrinking distances, accelerating communication, and giving us a world far different from that which previous generations had experienced.

“We shape our tools,” he said, “and then our tools shape us.” Technology, according to McLuhan [that is McLuhan’s idea, but it was first articulated in that phrase by Father John Culkin, SJ of Fordham University], is an extension of our own natural faculties. Just as a knife is an extension of the hand, and the wheel an extension of the leg, writing is an extension of speech and of memory. In this general metaphor, automobiles become extensions of our personal bodies, and the city an extension of our collective skin. Electronic communication is an extension of our nervous system, just as computers are extensions of our brains. Once extended, however, these technologies are “amputated.” They exist as external and independent objects, though we remain dependent upon them.

As a public figure, McLuhan came across as a kind of straight-faced stand-up comic. He would deliver his lectures [without the aid of notes or script] as a series of ironic, sometimes outrageous, one-liners, which he occasionally explained and expanded with an additional sentence or two. His insights and observations seemed to occur spontaneously, as he free-associated in a kind of one-sided conversation with his audience. His writing style was also nontraditional in its disregard for the expected conventions of linear development and logical transition.

McLuhan defended his style by saying that his statements were intended to be “probes” rather than truths. His role, as he saw it, was to awaken his audience from their hypnotic trance, to jolt them into seeing things in a new light. Emphasizing individual observation and analysis, he taught his students not to take anything for granted. In particular, he wanted them to try to understand how their environment was affecting them. That, of course, is not an easy task: we always have trouble perceiving the objective details of a situation in which we are completely immersed.

“We don’t know who discovered water,” McLuhan would say, “but we know it wasn’t the fish.” McLuhan played an important role in the development of contemporary communications theory. Thanks to him, we are a little less naive about technology and the way it impacts our lives.” Source:
Comment from Michael McLuhan regarding this video: “Cedric Smith plays Dad. He is unbelievably so like him it is spooky. Brilliant!”

2 Responses to “Marshall McLuhan on Historica Minutes”

  1. Thanks Alex for including this Historical Minute on your blog. I was involved in the project as a researcher working with Al Waxman who directed the piece. BTW the voice you hear at the end is Patrick Watson who produced the whole series and was a fan of Marshall’s. He introduced me to Al Waxman to work on the project. Al and I became fast friends as a result and spent many happy hours together catching Blue Jays games including a couple of World Series games. We used to park at the U of T parking lot in Spadina Circle and walk down Spadina to the ball game. Al loved to hold court as King of Kennsington as we preambled through his old neighborhood.

    • Bob, thanks for that background information. I knew Patrick Watson from my days in book publishing. He wrote a couple of works of fiction, one of which, “Alter Ego”, was published by Penguin Books. As a Penguin marketing rep I had to pick Patrick up from his mother’s apartment on St. George Street, north of Bloor, and escort him to various radio and TV stations for interviews. Of course he later went on to be the chairman of the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC). Al Waxman was a terrific actor and I remember he passed away the year he was scheduled to play Willie Loman in “Death of a Salesman” at Stratford. His too early passing was tragic. I always thought this Historica Minutes piece was a tad overdone, over-acted and something of a cliche of the absent-minded professor. But I have had to recant since Michael McLuhan told me that: “Cedric Smith plays Dad. He is unbelievably so like him it is spooky. Brilliant!” BTW, thank you for subscribing to my blog, now the official blog of the McLuhan Estate………AlexK

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: